The Lottery

The lottery is a gambling game or method of raising money, in which tickets are sold for the chance to win a prize, such as money or property. Lotteries are most commonly found in state governments, but they also exist in a few local and private lotteries. Some states prohibit the promotion of state-sponsored lotteries, while others endorse them and regulate them. The lottery is one of the most popular gambling activities in the world.

During the immediate post-World War II period, lottery revenues allowed states to expand their array of social safety nets without having to raise especially onerous taxes on the middle and working classes. However, by the 1960s that arrangement began to crumble because of inflation and the cost of the Vietnam War.

State officials soon came to realize that they could not sustain the expansion of government services without an alternative source of revenue. The solution was the lottery. The initial argument was that lotteries were “painless” taxes, because players voluntarily spend their money and the winners thereby receive public goods for free. This is a flawed argument, as voters expect their elected representatives to prioritize the welfare of citizens over all other considerations, including whether lottery proceeds should be spent on a particular project.

As a result, state-run lotteries are dependent on broad popular approval and have been able to fend off attempts to abolish them. In addition, they develop extensive specific constituencies, including convenience store operators (who provide the retail outlets for lotteries); lottery suppliers (heavy contributions to state political campaigns are widely reported); teachers (in those states in which a portion of the proceeds is earmarked for education); and state legislators, who quickly become accustomed to a steady flow of relatively painless tax revenues.

Moreover, the lottery industry is often highly lucrative and does not lend itself to general oversight. As a consequence, policy decisions are made piecemeal and incrementally, and the overall public interest is taken into account only intermittently.

Some moral critics of the lottery argue that it is regressive, because those who play the most are the poor and working classes. They are paying into the lottery with the false hope that they will become rich, but in fact they are simply enabling state officials to avoid more onerous taxes on the affluent.

Other moral critics argue that the lottery is unjust, because it is a form of “taxation by anticipation.” In the era of anti-tax activism, this is a powerful argument, because it suggests that state officials are stealing from those who have least to spare. The truth is, of course, that lottery proceeds do not help the neediest. In reality, the bulk of lottery proceeds is used for the general operation of state government and for advertising. Only a tiny percentage of the proceeds is allocated to public goods, and that figure is rapidly declining. A few dollars a week from millions of people is not much of a windfall for the common good.

Comments are closed.